Book of the month: Baalu Girma

This book came to my attention at the Cheltenham Literature Festival, during one of the 14 events I took part in as the festival’s Literary Explorer in Residence this year. The event in question was called the International Bookshelf. It involved me discussing trends in world-literature publishing with European Literature Network founder Rosie Goldsmith and translator extraordinaire Daniel Hahn (whose recent book If This Be Magic is a fascinating exploration of how Shakespeare has been translated around the world).

We each shared some of our favourite reads of the past year. Jeyamohan, Bachtyar Ali and Hanna Komar’s books were some of mine. Julia Franck’s Worlds Apart, translated by Imogen Taylor, Nino Haratischwili’s The Lack of Light, translated by Ruth Martin and Charlotte Collins, and Fiston Mwanza Mujila’s The Villain’s Dance, translated by Roland Glasser, were some of Rosie’s.

The Ethiopian classic Oromay by Baalu Girma, translated from the Amharic by David DeGusta and Mesfin Felleke Yirgu, was one of Daniel’s.

Published during the 1980s, soon after the events it depicts, Oromay follows Tsegaye, a journalist and senior figure in Ethiopia’s Ministry of Information who is tasked with relaying the regime’s attempts ‘to fix the Eritrean problem’ to the public. The government’s solution to defusing ‘the sectarian time bombs the colonialists planted’, which see Ethiopia and Eritrea locked in a bloody feud over sovereignty to this day, is to launch the Red Star Campaign – a military onslaught inside Eritrea to subdue ‘insurgents’ and unify the territory. It claims this will take only three months.

Leaving his beautiful fiancée Roman behind in Addis Ababa, Tsegaye heads to Asmara. There he encounters the equally beautiful Fiammetta, along with a mass of old feuds and raw wounds that complicate, challenge and ultimately rewrite the story he believes about himself and the story he is trying to tell his compatriots.

The tone of this novel is wonderfully engaging. Written largely in the first person (with occasional, wistful interjections from a voice that calls itself ‘the author’), Tsegaye’s narrative is direct and often very funny. Girma has an eye for the ridiculous, drawing secondary characters in memorable terms – one official ‘has a small face and a bald patch on his head that makes him look like a squash’. Another is so cutting and angular in his approach that ‘even his Afro, though thinning, has sharp edges.’ Tsegaye is similarly open about many of his limitations and not above poking fun at himself.

There are also passages of great beauty, particularly the descriptions of Asmara. There, when dusk settles, ‘the sun, like a shy Eritrean bride in all her braided glory, goes to hide under the horizon, setting it aglow with twilight rays.’

These depictions flirt with exoticization. But in case we begin to wonder whether Girma may have fallen victim to some of Tsegaye’s propaganda, and be seeing Eritrea through the same reductive, objectifying lens that seems to inform the Derg regime’s decisions, the author leaves us in no doubt as to his subtle grasp of the mechanics of language. When Tsegaye briefs his colleagues on the vocabulary they should use in their propaganda, Girma shows us both the limits of his protagonist’s understanding of what he is dealing with and his own, humane and far-reaching grasp of the way people work:

‘So fix your bayonets and charge! I am referring, of course, to the tools of our trade, our pens and pencils. I should be more careful. We need to refrain from using violent words like kill, stab, beat, charge. As you know, the situation here in Eritrea is complex. Every family in Asmara has someone – a husband or wife, a brother or sister, an aunt or uncle – who fled into the bush. Our propaganda should not lump everyone together.’

When we believe we are being most empathetic and insightful, Girma shows us, we may in fact be at our most callous and blind.

Girma’s ‘war of bandwidths and frequencies’, and his consideration of the role of storytelling in winning battles, is only one of the aspects of this novel that make it feel uncannily relevant to now. Another is the consideration of leadership and what it takes to bring people with you. The novel features a number of charismatic strongmen, most notably the party’s Chairman, whose eloquence cements his hold over his subordinates.

But it is another kind of leader who ultimately commands Tsegaye’s greatest loyalty and respect. Colonel Wolday, whom Tsegaye accompanies to the front on the perilous mission to capture Peak 1702, defies orders to stay with his soldiers in the face of defeat. His fate is the most poignant of all the disasters depicted in the novel, easily comparable in its power to the death of El Sordo in Hemingway’s For Whom the Bell Tolls.

It is in Wolday’s company that Tsegaye learns the meaning of the words he threw around so casually in his briefing. With this comes some astonishing insights into the psychology of conflict and the mental and emotional impact of combat:

‘After two weeks of unremitting devastation and hellish noise, you get used to it. You might even miss it. You don’t know why you feel that way – it’s crazy to miss an inferno. It’s one group of humans with clenched teeth determined to eliminate another group of humans, like beasts. It disgusts you, sickens you, and you hate yourself. Why did God make you part of such a vicious species?

[…]

‘When you came face-to-face with death, how did it feel? Were you heroic, bravely fighting on, or were you a coward, trying to hide? You gained some knowledge, learned new facts about yourself. What you discovered is that you’re not quite the person you thought you were. The image you had of yourself all these years – of your strengths, your softer side, what made you tick – you just found out that it is a myth, a lie. It disgusts you, sickens you, and you hate yourself.’

These reflections are particularly striking when considered alongside the work of Alemseged Tesfai, the celebrated Eritrean author who has depicted the same conflict in his fiction, drawing on his experience fighting with the Eritrean People’s Liberation Front. As I write in Relearning to Read (and have also explored in a review of his translation of Tesfaye Gebreab’s The Nurenebi File on this blog), his work features similar humour, humanity and unflinching insight into the personal horrors conflict exposes. Reading the fiction of two such towering talents, who share such facility for unravelling their characters’ fears, hopes and shame, but write from opposite sides of the battle lines brings home the claims made repeatedly throughout Oromay that this is a clash of brothers, a conflict made all the crueller by the many things its warring factions share.

The knowledge of Girma’s fate adds another layer to this. Oromay (the word means ‘done, finished, the end, it’s over’ in Amharic, as Tsegaye explains) was banned for six months after its publication. Then, on Valentine’s Day 1984, Baalu Girma disappeared, believed murdered by the Derg regime as revenge for his exposing depiction of it in this novel.

In light of this, the occasional interjections of the authorial voice in the narrative feel particularly poignant.

‘Do you remember me? If not, that’s fine.

‘In the beginning was the word, the word was the author, and the author was the word.

‘Tsegaye is asleep now, but his story continues.

‘Life does not stay still – it’s always moving, weaving together one existence with another to make its web.’

Yes, Baalu Girma. We remember you. Your work continues to reach new readers and speaks now beyond its moment, weaving its wisdom and insight into many other webs.

Oromay by Baalu Girma, translated from the Amharic by Oromay by David DeGusta and Mesfin Felleke Yirgu (MacLehose Press, 2026)

Ethiopia: home rule

IMG_0372

There are several strong contenders out there for Ethiopia, but Maaza Mengiste’s Beneath the Lion’s Gaze was one of the first to catch my eye. I wasn’t the only one to like the sound of the critically acclaimed debut novel – the day after I finished it, Bradley stopped by the blog to say he was reading and really enjoying it. Clearly the book was a popular choice.

Drawing on the overthrow of Emperor Haile Selassie in 1974, which forced Mengiste’s family to flee Ethiopia, Beneath the Lion’s Gaze traces the fall out of national events in individual lives. The narrative focuses on the family of an eminent Addis Ababa doctor, Hailu, who is struggling to keep his terminally ill wife alive against her wishes and who fears that his youngest son Dawit may be the next wounded revolutionary brought into the hospital for him to treat. At the start of the novel, Hailu has cast-iron confidence in his sense of right and wrong, born of years of making life-and-death decisions; yet, as society unravels around him, the lines begin to blur and when a horrifically tortured girl is brought to him to be patched up, Hailu finds his old certainties crumbling.

Like A Long Way Gone (my Sierra Leonean choice) the novel contains some of the most extreme descriptions of physical violence going. From brief glimpses, such as the pregnant woman ‘pleading at the foot of a man with stones for eyes and a plunging bayoneted rifle in his hand’, to extended scenes, including the interrogation of the small boy Berhane, the book bristles with outraged testimonies to the cruelty of its era – many of which will stay with readers long after they turn the final page.

Mengiste’s writing is excellent throughout. Perhaps the best proof of this for a child of the 1980s like me is the way that she manages to bring home the famines that ravaged rural Ethiopia throughout much of the final decades of the 20th century – and flooded Western TV screens, almost normalising images of extreme hunger for an entire generation. Through the eye-witness accounts of Dawit’s friend, Mickey, Mengiste cuts through the complacency that time and familiarity breed to shame readers with the horror of what happened once again:

‘This is how a man tills his land: behind cattle that are tied to one end of a plow that he uses to dig and lift and turn the ground. He holds a stick in one hand and the end of the plow in the other. At the end of that stick is a rope that he uses to whip the animals when they tire from the hot sun and the lack of water and simple hunger. A man works like this every day, every month, year after year, behind his cattle, his hand attached to a plow that has dug its own imprints into his calloused palms. He speaks to no one but himself, he hears nothing but his own slavish grunts as he pushes his plow into dirt, willing a crop to grow from unforgiving ground, praying daily for more rain. But it didn’t rain in 1972 in the north, my friend, and the farmer had no crops. The rains did not come as they should, and when the rains failed, the crops failed, and when the crops failed, the farmer grew hungry, and when he grew hungry, his cattle also grew hungry, because a farmer will feed his cattle before himself. When the cattle began to die, the farmer gathered his family and tried to walk to the nearest village, the nearest aid shelter, the nearest anywhere where he could hold out his proud hand and beg for food. But everyplace he went was the same as what he had left. They are starving here in Wello, Dawit. They are starving in Tigre and Shoa. We have lived in the city and we have forgotten about these people.’

Mengiste stretches these observations over a finely crafted plot, like canvases on a frame. Drawing in each character, the story moves from conflict to conflict, ratcheting up the tension with every chapter. I found myself gripping the Kindle in fear on several occasions – particularly in the scene where the soldiers come to search Hailu’s house for Dawit.

This solid structure means that the book can take the weight of the many larger questions its author heaps upon it. We find ourselves engaged in religious debates about where the line between accepting God’s will and working to ameliorate your situation should be and political reflections on the conditions needed to effect a revolution. In addition, we witness the events that can turn friendship into hatred, and discover a range of unsettling facts about life in post-revolution Ethiopia – such as the bullet fee families had to pay to receive the body of anyone shot by the authorities.

This is the sort of book that has the power to seem to stop time while the hours fly past. Gripping and thought-provoking, it sweeps you along to the final pages with just the right mix of emotional engagement and historical context. I’ll be adding Mengiste to the post-world watch list – I can’t wait to see what she comes up with next.

Beneath the Lion’s Gaze by Maaza Mengiste (Vintage Digital, 2010)