This was a recommendation from an Eritrean friend of mine. She had read Sulaiman Addonia’s The Consequences of Love not long after it came out in 2008 and enjoyed it. If I was looking for Eritrean literature in English, this was her top tip.
I had my reservations: a brief scan of Addonia’s biography revealed that, although he was born in Eritrea to an Eritrean mother, he has spent very little of his life there, having fled to Sudan and subsequently Saudi Arabia as a young child. He now lives and writes in London – could his work really be counted as Eritrean?
Then I thought about my friend’s own story. Like Addonia, she was driven from Eritrea, which has long been in the grip of a regime so oppressive that Reporters Without Borders ranks the country below North Korea for press freedom. The danger is such that my friend has been unable to visit her family there since she left, and her mother has never met her son-in-law and grandchild as a result. I began to wonder if such stories of separation and displacement were not as much a part of Eritrean life as the experiences of those who’ve stayed put.
Exile is also central to Addonia’s novel, which is set in the late 1980s, towards the end of Eritrea’s bitter 30-year war with Ethiopia. Like its author, the central character, 20-year-old Naser, has spent his teenage years in Saudi Arabia. Yet, although he has escaped the perils of conflict, he finds himself hemmed in by a whole range of other restrictions in Jeddah, where religious police scour the streets for people who break the strict behaviour codes, lovers are flogged and executed in Punishment Square and the vitriolic sermons of the blind imam blare through the city.
Lonely and anxious for the mother he left behind in Eritrea, Naser faces a life of isolation, until a mysterious, veiled woman drops a love letter at his feet one day. But in a society where communication between unmarried men and women is banned, it will take all Naser and his secret admirer Fiore’s courage and ingenuity if they are to give their happiness a chance.
Naser’s world is one where direct emotional expression is outlawed. Whether they are yearning for their homelands or pining for lovers, he and his cronies must shroud and sublimate their feelings so as to avoid chastisement at the hands of the ever-watchful authorities.
Such repression in this ‘world of black and white’ can have surprising results as blocked emotions and impulses play out through other means. There is Jasim’s café – where wealthy older men coerce the waiters, including Naser, into being their sexual partners until they get married and have a legitimate outlet for their libido – and there is the thriving trade in banned books, including Tayeb Salih’s Season of Migration to the North (my Sudanese pick), through which the characters live vicariously from inside the country Jasim describes as ‘the biggest prison in the world’. In addition, creativity blossoms, in the shape of Fiore’s drawings, the lovers’ impassioned letters, and the inventive means by which they get messages to one another. As Naser puts it, ‘caged emotions make poets out of all of us, even the illiterate’.
Caged emotions also make for a compelling story. In this tale of ‘love before sight’, the scene where Fiore is finally able to remove her hijab and the lovers come face to face after months is very moving. The sky-high stakes also make for a nail-biting conclusion, although, for my money, the final unravelling is too heavily foreshadowed to come as a surprise. However other readers may feel the dramatic irony creates a tension all its own.
Taken as a whole, though, this is a thoroughly engrossing and often beautifully written portrayal of what happens when regimes and laws run counter to human needs and emotions. As Naser puts it, it is the story of an individual’s struggle to ‘do what it takes to get a life that is rightfully [his]’ – a struggle that, by the sound of it, many Eritreans know all too well.
The Consequences of Love by Sulaiman Addonia (Vintage Digital, 2008)
It would be difficult to love this blog more if I tried, I feel like I’ve stumbled on some sort of a literary Alladin’s cave and am very excited! Thankyou!
Wow, thanks very much.
I never thought reading less well known (to me) works from authors in far flung countries would spark my interest, but you made me want to widen my horizons. I agree with above post, it is indeed like Aladdin’s cave
That’s a lovely comment, thanks Cee. Enjoy the adventure!
This one – and indeed, your other north-east African suggestions – sound wonderful. Thanks!
Thanks – hope you enjoy them!
Pingback: Review: The Consequences Of Love « eleutherophobia
I, too, loved this book, couldn’t put it down, was very moved by the situations Naser finds himself in and can highly recommend it… I am so amazed by the books which come from countries such as this, where the human spirtit is not crushed but speaks out with wisdom, often with grace, while describing quite terrible oppressions. Just found this blog while hunting to see if the author had written any more (yet) and wonder if liberal London has taken away some of his skills – hope not!
Me too! Let me know if you find anything…
Sadly, google hadn’t any news about another books … he works in London, but at what, they don’t say…
I am very inspired. I am planning to start with the book written by my country fellow Sulaiman Addonia!!
Great – I hope you enjoy it!
Wow, thank you so much for creating this amazing book list. I originally saw a Facebook post of you on a TED episode. I’m simple at awed that you did this. I will use your blog’s book selection to navigate my way back into reading. Better than Oprah’s book club!
Hi I just saw this and want to underline how fantastic the book is … I mean, The Consequnces of Love – it is so brilliant, yet I can’t find any more books by this guy. AM glad your blog is still here, Martha!
Pingback: Reading the World – The List – Scott's Blog